April 6, 2026

Why Chasing Calm Can Sometimes Make Things Harder

By Bethany MacGillivray, MCP-AT, RCC, RCAT

Here is something I hear often — and honestly, something I have noticed in myself too.

When we are feeling overwhelmed or anxious, what we crave most is the opposite. Stillness. Quiet. Calm. That deep exhale we have been waiting all day to take.

Which makes complete sense. Of course we want relief from the discomfort we are carrying.

But here is what I have come to understand, both through my training as a Somatic Experiencing® Practitioner (SEP™) and through my own lived experience: sometimes jumping straight to calm can actually feel more destabilizing, not less. Not because rest is bad, or because you are doing something wrong — but because the gap between where your nervous system currently is and where you want it to be is simply too wide to cross all at once.

I sometimes think of it like allowing something frozen to thaw gradually. This is a metaphor for the gentleness I find helpful, rather than a literal explanation of how the nervous system works.

So if you have ever tried to "just relax" and ended up feeling worse, more restless, or strangely more on edge — you were not failing at rest. Your body was simply being honest about where it was.

When Your Nervous System Is Trying to Protect You

Woman wrapped in a soft linen blanket seated at a window, representing nervous system protection and the chronic readiness that somatic counselling gently addresses at Soul Flow Therapy Port Moody BC

Here is what is actually happening in those moments.

After sustained stress, I sometimes notice a familiar sense of readiness or tension. People can experience this differently, and it is useful to explore what is happening without assuming a single explanation.

The problem is that when everything in us is set to "on," dropping suddenly to "off" does not feel like relief. It feels unfamiliar. Sometimes it feels unsafe. The contrast alone can be enough to send the system back into activation — which is why so many people find that meditation, deep breathing, or a quiet weekend away does not quite land the way they hoped it would.

This is not a personal failing. It is physiology.

And it is actually really useful information — because it points us toward a different question. Rather than asking how do I get calm faster, we can start asking what does my nervous system actually need in order to feel safe enough to settle?

That shift in question is, in many ways, the beginning of somatic work.

What Somatic Therapy Actually Focuses On

Somatic Experiencing® (SE™) is a body-based approach to healing developed by Dr. Peter Levine. Rather than trying to override the nervous system, SE™ works with it — following the body's own signals and rhythms rather than pushing past them.

Where traditional talk therapy primarily explores thoughts, patterns, and behaviours, somatic therapy also attends to what is happening in the body — the tension, the activation, the places where stress and past experience have quietly taken up residence.

Within Somatic Experiencing® and body-based approaches, there's an understanding that our memories and experiences are not stored only in our minds, they can live in the body too — in the tightness across the shoulders, the shallow breath that has become a habit, the low hum of alertness that does not quite switch off even when everything is, technically, fine.

As a Registered Clinical Counsellor and Somatic Experiencing® Practitioner, I draw on body awareness alongside conversation. We explore sensations and responses gently, guided by your preferences and comfort.

Building a Breadcrumb Trail Back to Yourself

Woman with one hand on her heart and one on her belly in a grounded seated position, representing body awareness and resourcing in Somatic Experiencing® sessions at Soul Flow Therapy Port Moody BC

One of the things I find most meaningful about this work is something we call resourcing — the process of building a breadcrumb trail that leads back to a felt sense of support.

This is not about forcing yourself to feel better. It is about noticing what already feels okay, even slightly. And sometimes that is not calm exactly — sometimes it is neutral. A place in the body that feels neither activated nor distressed. That neutral is actually a remarkable and worthy starting point.

From there, we build. Slowly, and with genuine care.

Two ideas sometimes guide this exploration in SE™. Titration means approaching a little at a time. Pendulation involves noticing shifts between sensations that feel more activating and those that feel more settled or neutral. We can explore this gently, guided by your comfort, without forcing a particular response.

Think of it less like a dramatic breakthrough and more like building a strong foundation — brick by brick, with enough space between each one for things to actually set.

Why Going Slowly Is Not the Same as Going Nowhere

Some therapeutic approaches do work with full activation — the kind of release that can feel cathartic and powerful. And for some people, at the right time, there is a place for that. But it also requires capacity to be there first. Without that foundation, intense experiences can leave us feeling depleted rather than relieved. Spent rather than supported.

What I aim to offer is something gentler by design. We build slowly so that what we build actually holds.

This work comes from a harm reduction perspective. The intention is never to take away the tools you already use to get through your days. You are not being asked to drop what has been keeping you afloat. We are simply adding to your internal toolkit over time — gently expanding what is available to you, without pulling the rug out from under anything that is currently working.

If this theme of rest, capacity, and the cost of always being in "go mode" resonates with you, I explored it more in Balancing Rest and Responsibility While Learning to Say Yes to Yourself — it sits alongside this post in a way that might feel familiar.

It also means you are not navigating any of this alone. Part of what I try to model in sessions — and what I am genuinely still learning myself — is that it is possible to move through difficult material without being swept away by it. That steadiness, that sense of having ground beneath you, is something we build together.

What This Can Look Like in a Session at Soul Flow Therapy

Warm rattan chair beside a large tropical plant in a calm neutral space, representing the welcoming and gentle counselling environment at Soul Flow Therapy in Port Moody BC

Sessions here are gentle by design. We might slow down and simply notice a sensation in the body — not to analyze it or fix it, just to acknowledge that it is there. We might track what shifts when you bring your attention toward something that feels a little more settled. We might work with breath, with movement, with creative expression — depending on what feels right for you on any given day.

There is no homework to get right. No performance required. Just a curious, unhurried exploration of what your body has been carrying — and what it might be ready, very gently, to begin to release.

If you have been curious about somatic therapy but were not quite sure what to expect, or if you have explored other approaches in the past that felt like too much too soon, I offer a free 20-minute consultation — no pressure, just a chance to see if working together feels like a fit.

Want to explore Somatic Experiencing® further? Dr. Peter Levine's work and additional resources are available at Somatic Experiencing® International.

Book a Free Consultation

This post is for reflection and educational purposes. It is not a substitute for individual counselling, diagnosis, or medical advice.

‍